Fewer “accessory dwelling units” were permitted in 2021 than in 2020 in Salt Lake City, a leader in the state for allowing backyard “granny flats.” Those numbers are sure to disappoint policy makers who are hoping that ADUs can be a major tool in easing the Wasatch Front’s housing crunch.
The right is limited to owner-occupied, single-family zoned properties. ADUs are illegal in every other zoning category in the city.
We asked Planning Director Nick Norris why the numbers continue to be so low. 33 ADUs permitted in 2019, 34 in 2020, 27 in 2021. He said seven additional units should be added to that 2021 number, bringing it to 34.
What’s the holdup? Is it the conditional use process (required of all external ADUs), the owner-occupancy requirement, high fees, inflation?
“One thing that is consistent across cities in the US,” Norris told us, “is numbers are always low when the regulations require an approval process like the conditional use process, when the fees are high, when there are owner occupancy requirements, and when there are a lot of [design] standards to comply with.”
Such restrictions are common, he said, as policymakers tend to respond to members of the public wary of the changes. Yet things also tend to evolve politically.
“The cities where ADUs are beginning to provide a noticeable impact to the housing stock are those that have removed or simplified their ADU regulations,” Norris noted.
The Planning Division’s 2021 ADU Annual Report has been sent to the City Council office, and is awaiting to be scheduled for a briefing.